Saturday, November 19, 2011

Occupy, and Cause and Effect

The intensity of the Occupy movement has been growing week by week, reaching a crescendo this past week with the apparent coordinated shutdowns by US cities and then the backlash, followed by unwarranted pepper-sprayings, followed by viral postings of those incidents. A local Portlander who I follow on Twitter has been a regular at OccupyPortland and I noticed that he suggested that people should follow @_Capitalism_. I read through several pages worth of @_Capitalism_'s tweets and they are a witty and potentially sobering expose of the ills of capitalism as currently practiced.

This got me thinking more deeply about the larger impact of the Occupy movement. The Great Recession (that we are either in the tail of or which recently passed, depending on which economist you read) has occurred at a time when many college graduates are having difficulty finding jobs. The bailout of financial institutions followed by publication of bonus plans for financial executives have also occurred at the same time. On the surface, these two factors: a very sluggish job market and the excessive bonuses and bailouts certainly justify the indignation witnessed in the Occupy movement. If you add to those factors the polarization of Washington politics, we are clearing in a defining moment of time.

I have always believed that technological innovation would drive skills enhancements for many jobs. There would be less of a need for highly repetitive, mechanistic work, and more need for thoughtful analysis. A good example is the work of a nurse where the ability to read and respond to digital monitoring of a patient's condition has become routine. There is more expected of us at work now that we have automated some of the routine calculations and steps of a task. It is also true that some of the finer mechanical skills that technicians applied throughout the latter half of the nineteenth and the entire twentieth century have become less in demand as those workers have been replaced by automation.

It's difficult enough determining how best to use new technology on the job, more so to figure out the right mix of human and machine resources for an economy as a whole. It is not a zero-sum game where more technology at work means less humans at work. As computers started monitoring patients, or assembly-line operations, the skills required of people to work with that monitoring equipment changed. New industries were created to produce innovative gadgets and peripheral devices, and of course, software. Back when computers were starting to appear on office desks, who could have predicted that we would be funding companies to create social media applications for mobile phones a generation or so later?

There are clear indications that we need to continually learn how to use and shape technology if we are to be gainfully employed in occupations that challenge us and have meaning to us. As exponential growth in some factors of technology continue, it will be critical for us to keep up.

In their book, Race Against the Machine, Brynjolfsson and McAfee refer to the second half of the chessboard, a term coined by Ray Kurzweil to indicate a point where "an exponentially growing factor begins to have a significant economic impact." As the authors put it:
"Kurzweil’s point is that constant doubling, reflecting exponential growth, is deceptive because it is initially unremarkable. Exponential increases initially look a lot like standard linear ones, but they’re not. As time goes by—as we move into the second half of the chessboard—exponential growth confounds our intuition and expectations. It accelerates far past linear growth..."

As evidence of the fact that we are truly experiencing technological change that confounds us, they refer to Google's automobile driving itself, IBM's Watson consistently winning at Jeopardy and GeoFluent's ability to do real-time translation of online chat messages.

A partial answer for the extremely sluggish job growth we've seen over the past year is, I believe, the technological unemployment resulting from this exponential growth. Technological innovation is seen in many traditional industries, and in fact is responsible, according to Brynjolfsson and McAfee, for separating some of the leading companies from their competitors.

As for the increasing income disparity between the 99% and the 1%, exponential technological growth will only exacerbate this. Owners of capital, which includes corporate ownership of technology, have reaped greater profits from the explosive productivity of these non-human resources. Unless the majority of workers (by which I mean workers without significant ownership in an enterprise) can sell their skill at a rate that keeps up with the growth of technological capital, then workers will necessarily earn a smaller piece of the pie.

As a student of economics, this is how I see what is happening in our current crisis. It is not a moral judgement by any means, but represents what appears, to me, to be happening. As an experienced software engineer, I see every day who competes and am aware of those that do not, and without self-training and pro-active behavior, I see the crisis getting worse for most people.

So, it is not purely the mis-administration of public funds to prop up reckless financiers, nor the greed of the 1% that is necessarily responsible for our current economic climate. There are longer-term forces at work which require not only good stewardship from our corporate and government leaders but good stewardship by each and every person of their own career.

I started out this post by addressing the Occupy movement and I hope to have shed some light on the longer-term forces that are important when looking at cause and effect. Long-term technological progress does not explain the reckless behavior of Wall Street firms trying to make money on securities based on bad mortgages. But it does explain at least part of the increasing disparity in income we've seen in our society over the past twenty or thirty years. In the spirit of cooperation, I wonder if we, as citizens, might be able to find ways to help ourselves become better prepared for a more technologically-oriented future, while at the same time using our newly-acquired skills to monitor and police our society so that irresponsible behavior in the so-called white-collar world is more transparent and more easily deterred.

Leaving this open-ended, without answer at this point gives me an opportunity to think and write more on these possibilities. I'd love to hear your thoughts.


21 comments:

Buzz Hill said...

I would like it if you would turn your ideas into a productive conversation(s). The media is moving from a publishing/broadcast to a conversation model.

Bob Uva said...

Buzz,

By entering comments, we are engaging in a conversation. Maybe I don't get what you were getting at.

Bob

Buzz Hill said...

Sounds to me as if you get exactly what I am talking about, Bob. Our conversation (as comments to your post) has the potential of attracting others and helping to better distribute the useful memes you have originated. I could be wrong.

Anonymous said...

Этот пост — одно из редких исключений, когда читаешь с удовольствием и что-то для себя выносишь. Спасибо Вам. Добавлю в избранное[url=http://voronezh.recikl.ru/].[/url] :)

Anonymous said...

The reason for this is cheap lumigan Training your muscles to burn out to failure can be counter-productive for gaining lean muscle
If you have had problems with your gall bladder and your doctor thinks it could burst, you may be faced with surgery to have it removed buy cymbalta cost If you or your loved one have suicidal thoughts it is time to take serious care of your health!
Now, shouldn't you listen to their recommendations as well? female Viagra uk Cynergy TK is a natural extract that helps in the production of Collagen and Elastin
When the body is unable to provide the wound with enough blood flow for the wound to be cleaned and repaired, the rate of healing can be vastly impaired, even stopped iressa Keeping a migraine diary is essential
With the advent of new technology and treatments, there is much scope of improvement in the dental health care that patients can look forward to Get Exelon Fad diets usually consist of eating only one type of food

Anonymous said...

Choose your calories wisely!Dieting Tip #2 - Eat Breakfast!I can't stress how important this is buy lumigan I want to leave you with a list of the absolute BEST foods that will supercharge your energy levels
These kind of supplements generally contain about 5 or 6 natural ingredients whose properties increase HDL, lower LDL and any excess LDL that cannot be reprocessed they change into bile salts that are removed from the body cheap cymbalta 30% of all clinically depressed patients attempt suicide; half of those ultimately die by suicide.
This can burn a lot of calories every day, and can take away some of that pregnancy weight buy Viagra for women Yes, you might think it might be absurd and that it does not relate to you in any way
Next way to get rid of damaged hair is to be on a well balanced and nutritious diet iressa All you have to do is to keep up with the pace automatically set by the motor
It is truly unfortunate that most westerners have a stigma about natural health Cheapest Effexor Your triceps are larger muscles than your biceps, and what's more, they're functional muscles; they play a key role in such basic compound exercises as bench-pressing to pushing back an opponent in a football game

Anonymous said...

Look for something that contains only natural ingredients lumigan cost
* Frequent urination often and with urgency accompanied with incontinence
Well, I want to tell you something you can and will succeed generic cymbalta If depression makes youк life unbearable and colorless, you should help yourself somehow!
Tip #3 - Always Warm Up And Warm Down!A lot of guys make the mistake of not warming up their penis before they begin Viagra for women price Wherever we go we have choices that we can make
Atopic Eczema:Atopic eczema is one of the most common and popular types of eczema generic iressa I have used this application on my family over the years
Thankfully these are all easy to get hold of and fit into your daily diet, so eating the recommended fruits for diabetes is easy Where to buy Nevirapine Prices for instruction can range anywhere from thousands of dollars to free, depending upon the level of expertise being accessed

Anonymous said...

Xray cervical spine shows reduced disc space, osteophyte formation. unlocking your cell phone. And for that there is need to have a stable and strong base that is usually prepared with concrete. secretsline

Anonymous said...

Want your bad credit to be repaired or have a dispute with your credit report? facebook unlock. The jobs shortage was blamed on a “substantial backlog” in the number of jobless graduates from previous years – creating additional pressure on the employment market in 2010. surf internet anonymously free

Anonymous said...

There is a misconception among many; dental hygiene is the primary goal of orthodontics., vpn client no access. Vitamins help every important organ in your body function the way they should. When the police remove the abusers from the property they do not obtain the abusers addresses or likely places where the abusers could be staying, which could be passed on to the victim so that when a court order is obtained it could be served on the abusers at the given address(s). web server software free download. This article will share with you some simple tips on how to bring down those seemingly expensive brochure printing costs. update windows 2000 to windows xp

Anonymous said...

What they're just actually doing is giving people an incentive to spread it. Lace, ribbon, bows, fold, lotus leaf, threedimensional flowers and feathers, etc. mac vpn configuration. Issues concerning directing, planning, controlling and organizing are carried out professionally. Some think that power will do so, while some think that getting married is the answer., difference between lvpn. The problem, however, is that you need guidance to balance your overall health and vitality. vpn on iphone netgear

Anonymous said...

Besides, their body needs some time to heal up before they are ready for sex. So instead of taking on a highly risky affair for both your appliance as well as yourself it is best to call in a professional expert who can set things right by the usage of proper tools and techniques so that the areas requiring immediate attention can be instantly fixed to ward off any kind of impending mess., mutual fund no load. All inclusive resorts feature their best discounts and hotels add additional luxury to their getaways; the best thing about it is that there are adults only all inclusive vacation packages to meet every budget. http intranet mtnl in

Anonymous said...

Several classic candies offer customizing services to add that special touch to your wedding reception at prices that won’t break the bank. Think of juice detoxing as a healing cycle, which cleanses and reenergizes the body, providing it with nutritional support and vitality., gas radio remote controlled rc off road buggy car rtr. As long as the instructions are clear and easy to understand, more and more readers should respond to your sales brochure. ssl module

Anonymous said...

The rapid expansion of supercritical solution obtained the αasarone of fine particles. Few attractive ways to make it special are:1., https proxy tunnel. I even hear it from people close to me. xilince wow server v02

Anonymous said...

Today this is linked more with physical health than to do with impotence. You must know that the efficiency of the drug rehab center totally depends on the success of the treatment. ssl certificates us. One agenda debt alliance advantage for homeowners is a mortgage refinance. Yes, everything is done within that room itself, and you will not have to wait for weeks until the replacement artificial tooth arrives., network topology as. Natural or at home remedies for moisturizing the skin are also available. remote 3

Anonymous said...

This is most especially if you own a vegetable garden. Make sure the ordination credentials carries a seal and hand signature from an authorized member of the organization you request your credentials from. canadian controlled private corporation. Web page tracking or monitoring is essential to ensure that a user who uses a website for work purposes does not get frustrated and stop using the application because the downtime is very high. Spell the previous was mostly into foods, the latter was into detergents and individual assist., . mod proxy balancer. A little bit of research on the company and the past profile will guarantee you the peace of mind. what web server are they using

Anonymous said...

Improved customer response has resulted in banks extending their teaser rates. The content of gift hampers has evolved through the years., free soccer socks. It would just take a second for you to realize the uniqueness and the high quality of our products. oceanside village sc private beach

Anonymous said...

Ϻу brοther suggested I might
likе this web ѕite. He was once totаlly гіght.
This put up aсtually made my day. You can not consiԁer
simρly how so much tіme I hаԁ spent foг this information!
Thanκ you!

Stop by mу pаge: raspberry ketone side effects

Anonymous said...

Terrіfic poѕt hoωever I waѕ wanting to know if you
coulԁ ωrite a litte mοгe on this tоpic?
I'd be very grateful if you could elaborate a little bit more. Appreciate it!

Here is my website :: frontier internet

Anonymous said...

I don't even understand how I finished up right here, but I thought this publish was once good. I don't reаlizе who you аre however certainly you are going to a famоus blogger if уοu aren't already. Cheers!

My web blog: keywords: floristry

Anonymous said...

Today, while I was at work, mу ѕister stole mу iphone and tеsted to see if it сan survivе а twentу five foоt drop,
juѕt so she can be a youtube sensation. My iPaԁ is now destroуed and she has
83 views. I know thіs is сompletely off
topic but I had to shаre it with someοne!


My blog making money Online